Magisterial District Judge Caught Dismissing Her Own Traffic Tickets
In 2010, Magisterial District Judge Kelly Ballentine was issued three traffic citations, two for parking violations and one for having an out-of-date registration on her BMW sedan. However, when she failed to pay the tickets on time, summonses were sent to her. Ballentine, who had access to court system records, then proceeded to dismiss her own summonses, a move that would lead to her downfall.
Facing Criminal Charges
After being investigated by the Pennsylvania state attorney, Ballentine was charged with a number of violations, including conflict of interest, tampering with public records, and obstructing the administration of law. In total, nine of the charges were felony violations. Ballentine was put on paid leave until her case was resolved, and she eventually pleaded guilty to three counts. The remaining charges were dismissed by the Attorney General’s Office.
Ordered to Repay Salary and Benefits
The Judicial Conduct Board also initiated its own case against Ballentine for violating the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges and Article V of Pennsylvania’s constitution. The Pennsylvania’s Court of Judicial Discipline determined that Ballentine had violated the rules and the constitution “by virtue of her improper conduct by personally dismissing three traffic citations that were issued to her in 2010.” As a result, Ballentine was suspended without pay and ordered to repay the commonwealth the salary she received since the day she pleaded guilty, as well as the state’s share of her retirement and Social Security contributions.
The Consequences of Dismissing One’s Own Traffic Tickets
Ballentine’s conduct was considered extreme and brought the judicial office itself into disrepute. The Court of Judicial Discipline noted that “We cannot think of a purer example of conduct which prejudices the proper administration of justice.” Ballentine’s actions undermined the very heart of the judicial function and set a terrible example for others to follow.
Allowed Back on the Bench, But on Probation
Despite her egregious actions, Ballentine was allowed back on the bench in June, albeit on probation through 2014. Her actions serve as a reminder of the importance of integrity and impartiality in the judiciary and the need to uphold the rule of law, even when it comes to one’s own traffic tickets.